Crystal Ball: 2010 Home Sales Will Surprise – In a Good Way


Feb 4

Real estate

Some background:

From late summer through October 2009, Uncle Sam offered first-time buyers $8,000 if they bought a home by the end of November. As a country we “brought sales forward” – we convinced people who would otherwise have bought in December or January to buy in November.

It's Exciting!
How Sweet?

When the November numbers were released, the National Association of Realtors and the media feigned surprise that sales were so strong (up 7.4%). (“November home sales leap,” “November existing-home sales surge“).  But it was no surprise. Everyone watching the market knew it was going to happen.

Then in December, existing sales plunged 16.7%, even though the tax credit had been extended. This wasn’t a surprise to anyone watching the industry either. People who wanted to buy did so in November and by the time the extension was announced — just 34 days before it would’ve expired — nearly every person who could’ve used the credit had already made an offer. But “plunged” makes for good headlines.

Our prediction:

We have a crystal ball here at Estately: Home search traffic.

See, before prospective homebuyers apply for mortgages, or choose agents, or go to open houses, they dip their toes in the market by searching for homes on our site. When our traffic spikes, we see spikes in home buying a few months later. And we finally have some good news to report!

2010 will start slow–January sales will be off. (Estately’s partner agents helped a lot of people buy homes this January – many more so than last year – but we’re fairly certain that has more to do with us than the market.)

Sales will be low because people who would have put in an offer that would close this winter already did so in the fall — they wanted that $8,000. (Note: that means less competition if you are buying a home right now.) We also expect low sales for January because we saw soft traffic in November/December.

Spring and summer of 2010 will be different! Every year, there is an annual increase in people searching for real estate from December to January. But this year we are seeing a much bigger bump – 80% bigger.  This year we are seeing 40% more people searching for homes on Estately in January than we were in December. That’s a huge change in homebuyer sentiment.

Home search traffic is a leading indicator: we saw traffic really jump last August – three months before sales jumped in November.  Based on previous annual trends, this dramatically increased interest and traffic will translate to strong home sales this spring and summer.

Regionally, the Big Winners are Chicago, Atlanta, San Diego and Seattle with huge bumps. The rest of California – and especially Sacramento – not so great.

Here is a table ranking the markets we are in:

City Seasonal Bump

Chicago 64%

Atlanta 57%

San Diego 55%

Seattle 55%

Portland 47%

Bay Area 25%

Los Angeles 23%

Long Island 21%

Sacramento 15%
Rank City Seasonal Bump
1 Chicago 64%
2 Atlanta 57%
3 San Diego 55%
4 Seattle 55%
5 Portland 47%
6 Bay Area 25%
7 Los Angeles 23%
8 Long Island 21%
9 Sacramento 15%

Disclaimer: This is a short-term prediction. I’ve personally been a pessimist about the real estate market since 2004. But back then I jumped the gun, since the market continued to rise for 2 years. And I didn’t quite expect the magnitude of the 2006 correction, either (what a ride!).  Whatever happens in 2010, long term, I believe we’re in a holding pattern for stocks and home prices – there will be upward swings and downward swings. The Case Schiller index seems to show way less room for prices to go down than it did at the peak of the bubble and thankfully homebuilders have virtually stopped building. Mid- to Long-term home prices and sales are stabilizing.

And a nod to the contrary evidence out there is warranted: While Google Trends seem to contradict me (see Seattle Bubble for analysis), I’m skeptical of Google Trends as a measurement tool here – buzz about real estate, home prices, and mortgages can cause “real estate” searches, but browsing homes on an MLS-based search site like Estately means business.

Related Articles

DC9631255 - Sun Drenched Observatory

Barbecuing with Barack: You Can Be Obama’s Neighbor

As November nears and President Obama’s second term comes to a close, the first family prepares to bid farewell to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. What this means for you dreamers and schemers out there, is a rare chance to become Barry’s neighbor and best friend.

Read more
Estately Burger Map

America’s 5 Best and Worst Cities for Hamburgers

Saturday is National Hamburger Day, and here at Estately, we take burgers very seriously. So seriously in fact, that we combed through Yelp data to create this attractive map of America's best and worst cities for burgers.

Read more
beer map

The United States of Beer—A Rebuttal to Budweiser’s America

The King of Beers may be the brand most synonymous with America internationally, but the United States of America is 50 states strong, and each individual state deserves to be paired with a beer that best represents it. Here are Estately's suggestions...

Read more

18 Things You Should Know Before Moving to Palo Alto

Palo Alto is home to a couple of small tech companies you may have heard of - Facebook, Google and Hewlett Packard just to name a few. If you want to work a tech company and want to live near where you work, Palo Alto is a good place to be.

Read more
WA homeowner costs

What do Residents in Washington’s 25 Largest Cities Spend on Housing?

The general rule of homeownership is you shouldn't spend more than 28% of your income on housing. While that number is somewhat arbitrary, it certainly doesn't match what many Washington state residents are paying during a time of skyrocketing home prices.

Read more

7 U.S. Homes For Sale That Come With Outhouses

Once a necessary amenity for any home, the outhouse has been cast off by most, but not all, homeowners. Some homes have no shame in advertising their outdoor bathrooms so Estately searched thousands of real estate listings to find some of the best.

Read more

20 Things You Should Know Before Moving to Providence, Rhode Island

Providence, Rhodes Island – the New England mecca of history, creativity, and education. Fall in love with its gorgeous fall foliage and bustling cultural offerings. If you're considering relocating to Providence, here are a few things you should know first...

Read more

Boston-area home prices by transit stop

It's no secret Boston-area home prices are among the highest in the country, but Estately wanted to show how those prices vary depending on which transit stop a home is near. To do this, Estately analyzed the last six months of home sales within a half-mile radius of each Boston-area transit stops.

Read more